Does Sweet Potato Pie Need To Be Refrigerated? Does It Go Bad?

Does Sweet Potato Pie Need To Be Refrigerated?

What is a name? Wise people had told us to judge a book by its content, not by the cover. The same can be said for a kind of food also. Sometimes we befooled ourselves when we reject some dishes without tasting them as the names of them don’t draw our interest. For example, a sweet potato pie is a kind of dessert that has come from the old days, and surely most of us just ignore it without giving it a try. But hey!! Avoid taking the wrong route, just give it a try. I am sure you’ll be amazed at having it.

Does Sweet Potato Pie Need To Be Refrigerated?  I am supposed to give the answer to this and to find the answer I’ll go all the way to collect some valuable factors and features about the sweet potato pie and many other things to know the calibre of this kind of pie. So, here you go-

What Is Sweet Potato Pie?

Sweet Potato pie is a kind of traditional dessert made of simply mashed sweet potato and some other very common ingredients that are always seen in your kitchen, is deeply spiced and spiked with bourbon and again topped with homemade marshmallow whipped cream. This silky smooth-finished pie has traditionally been served on holidays and Thanksgiving in Southern USA over the pumpkin pie for ages.

Apart from unbaked pie crust, if you can manage to get some mashed sweet potatoes, butter, sugar, eggs, whole milk, bourbon, and then cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and vanilla for the desired taste and flavour, then it would take no time to prepare your favourite. After baking is almost done, you have to apply homemade marshmallow whipped cream as the topping that you’re surely looking for.

What If You Need To Make Sweet Potato Pie In Advance?

Suppose you’ve arranged a big Thanksgiving dinner at your place and now you have to prepare sweet potato pie in advance enabling you to serve them at the right time. That certainly will be a big concern for you. Because it contains eggs and milk that are not the kinds for staying good too long.

In that case, the best you can do to store the pies that have been made in advance is in a freezer. And the next day just a few hours before the party you can take them out and place them in a refrigerator for defrosting. In this way, the pies will be ready for serving. Perhaps, the frozen ones are not as good as the fresh ones, but if you keep them inside the wrap then the moisture may not affect them so much. Refrigeration will keep the pie in good condition for up to 3 days.

Also read: Does Lemon Meringue Pie Need To Be Refrigerated? Does It Go Bad?

Can You Leave Cooked Sweet Potato Pie Out Overnight?

If you want to leave out the cooked sweet potato pie overnight at room temperature, it means you’re inviting the invasion of bacteria in your pie. According to the USDA, still you can dare to do that, but for a maximum of 2 hours only. After that, it would be a subject to discard. Even you cannot save it by reheating it.

How Long Is Homemade Sweet Potato Pie Good For?

A homemade sweet potato pie doesn’t contain any so-called preservatives therefore you cannot expect it’ll last for a longer period at room temperature. Only an hour or two seems enough for it. But if you keep it in a refrigerator, it may last as many as 3 days. But the best way to keep the pie fresh for more time is to freeze it. A sweet potato pie can be stored in a freezer for up to 1 month by wrapping it properly in aluminum foil.

How To Store Sweet Potato Pie And Keep It Fresh?

Well, so far we’ve come to know that if you want to keep the pie good for as long as 1 month then a freezer would be the best bet. Unless a fridge can do the same for a maximum of 3 days. But also you need to wrap them with aluminium foil from all sides and then put it in an air-tight container, It will remain fresh and the texture and flavour will be as same as the fresh ones.

Also read: Does Apple Pie Need To Be Refrigerated After Baking?

Does Sweet Potato Pie Need To Be Refrigerated?

Generally, raw sweet potatoes don’t need to be refrigerated as they remain good at normal temperatures for a longer time. But as the sweet potato pie contains eggs and milk, it must be refrigerated to prevent those ingredients from being spoiled. Besides, bacteria can start to grow if the pie is not kept at less than 40°F. Unless having spoiled pie may cause some serious health issues.

But before keeping the pie in the refrigerator, you have to allow the pie to cool completely after baking is done. Then you have to cover the top of the pie with aluminum foil and then put it in an air-tight container only to prevent it from being soggy due to extra moisture.

Can Sweet Potato Pie Filling Be Frozen? How Long Can You Freeze It?

Apart from being refrigerated, the homemade sweet potato pie filling can be frozen easily and the result will be very encouraging. All you need to keep all the filling in an airtight freezer bag. But before that, don’t forget to thaw the pie filling completely, and then keep it in a bowl until the filling is allowed to cool down completely. This makes you enjoy the homemade sweet potato pie whenever you want.

Another research suggests that to avoid wastage, you have to freeze the filling in an ice cube tray. Once it is frozen, only then transferred into the freezer bags.

How To Reheat Sweet Potato Pie?

If you have some leftovers of sweet potato pie and you’ve stored it in a fridge, then before the next use the pies should be reheated to get the best taste and quality out of them. To make this possible you have to preheat the oven to 300°F and then you can place the pie on the baking pan for 20 minutes. The edges should be covered with aluminium foil. If the pies are taken out of the freezer, they should be defrosted first and then placed on the baking sheet. Here baking may take some more minutes to complete.

Can Sweet Potato Pie Go Bad?

Yes, sweet potato pie goes bad if it’s not stored properly. It means that if you leave it at room temperature for hours, the eggs and milk it may get spoiled and that turns the whole pie bad. You should allow the pie to cool completely before being kept in a fridge, unless the moisture may get trapped inside the pie leaving it soggy. Even if you don’t wrap the pie in an aluminum cover the pie before placing it in a fridge, the result will be the same.

Also read: Does Peach Pie Need to Be Refrigerated? Does It Go Bad?

Can You Get Food Poisoning From Sweet Potato Pie?

As we’ve already discussed eating wrongly stored sweet potato pie with bacteria growth may cause harm to your health. Especially, You can be affected by food poisoning and you may suffer from vomiting, diarrhoea, nausea, dehydration, etc. Therefore, if you find that the sweet potato pie has been kept at room temperature for more than an hour, you should throw it away instead of having it.


How Do You Know When A Sweet Potato Pie Is Done?

If you want to know if your sweet potato pie is done cooking, you have to watch carefully the colour of the filling. If the pie turns golden brown, it would suggest that your pie is done cooking. According to USDA sweet potato pie should be baked or cooked at 400°F for at least 25 minutes to get the best result. Remember, if the pie is undercooked, you could be suffered from food poisoning.

How Do You Get The Strings Out Of Sweet Potatoes?

Most of the strings are found close to the skin of the sweet potatoes. So they can be removed by peeling off the skin with a sharp paring knife of the sweet potatoes. If you bake the potatoes first you can peel off the skin easily using your hands only.

Why Did My Sweet Potato Pie Crack?

Well, this thing often happens due to improper watering. If you face too much watering in form of rain or irrigation at the end of the season may cause cracked sweet potatoes. Watering should be stopped 3-4 weeks before harvesting to avoid cracks.

Bottom Line

Sweet potato pie is one of its kind that cannot be ignored while you’re considering arranging a big fat dinner at your place on a very special day. Those who are yet to taste it…….. God Bless You!!!

Does Sweet Potato Pie Need To Be Refrigerated? So far we’re out to find a befitting reply to this question. Now we’re backing home as our finding is more than done. Hope you’ll get a reply to all your queries regarding this issue and that will help you to handle the matter better than before. See you, have a nice time!!!

Leave a Comment