Does Chess Pie Need to Be Refrigerated? Does It Go Bad?

Does Chess Pie Need to Be Refrigerated

“CHESS”- whenever you come across the name the only thing that immediately comes to your mind is a “Game of Thorne”. Since ancient times this warlike game has been popularly played by the royals and even by the commons. But no!! We are not here to discuss a game. It’s a kind of dessert that is commonly called a chess pie. There are many stories and logic behind this kind of name of a simple pie, but then…what’s in the name? Let’s go past everything and concentrate on the wonderful taste and flavour that your chess pie offers.

Does Chess Pie Need To Be Refrigerated? I knew I would have been asked this question. But I don’t want to reply in short. Instead, I wish to go through it to find out all the relevant things about the chess pie so that you can find more than a simple answer to get a better idea about it.

What Is Chess Pie?

Chess pie is a kind of soft and sticky, buttery, and extremely sweet dessert from Southern USA that has been considered the main dessert for the past few hundred years. This is made of a few simple ingredients like butter, sugar, and eggs. But as the thickening agent, some prefer flour while some use cornmeal. Even some of the bakers use both. That doesn’t make many differences, whenever no matter in what situation you serve it, you’ll be amazed to see how fondly people eat it. And… no one can eat just one.

Can I Leave A Chess Pie Out Overnight?

Mostly you leave chess pie out overnight to cool it. But as it contains eggs and dairy products you cannot expect it to stay good at room temperature for a longer period. You have a limited time of 2-4 hours to keep it at normal temperature. But after that, you must have to make an arrangement to place it in a cooler place, and in that case, a refrigerator would be the best bet for you.

How To Store Chess Pies So That They Stay Fresh For Longer?

Storing a chess pie will be a big concern for you as much as preparing it. As it’s a custard type of pie without containing fruits, it would be a challenging task to keep it fresh for a longer time. If it’s left out at room temperature, you cannot go for more than 2-4 hours. But if you have lemon chess pie or chocolate chess pie, then you may get some extra hours to keep it at a normal temperature. But in all cases, keeping chess pie in a refrigerator is one of the best ideas to maintain its freshness for a few days. But keeping this kind of pie in a freezer might not go well with every type of it.

Read also: Does Sweet Potato Pie Need To Be Refrigerated? Does It Go Bad?

Does Chess Pie Need To Be Refrigerated?

However, if you want to keep your chess pie fresh for a few days, then as I told you, refrigerating is the best option for you. But here first you need to cool your baked pie and allow it to come to room temperature, and then you can place it in a refrigerator. Usually, it takes 2-3 hours to be cooled and after that, it can stay fresh for a good 3-4 days in a refrigerator. If you place a warm pie that comes directly from the baking process, then there would be very little time for the moisture to leave the pie and as a result, your chess may turn soggy with time.

Can You Freeze A Cooked Chess Pie?

Yes, chess pieces can be placed in a freezer for later use. But if it is a custard type and cream-based that contains milk or other dairy products, or if the chess pie has cornstarch in the filling, cannot be frozen as the result would not be good. Because the contents may get separated after thawing and the pie may turn soggy. Only the chess pie that contains fruits can be kept in a freezer for a few months. But before that, you have to cool the pie to room temperature, and then wrap it tightly in a plastic sheet, and finally, you can put it in a freezer bag. This will prevent the frozen pie from being crushed.

Read also: Does Cherry Pie Need To Be Refrigerated? Does It Go Bad?

How Long Can A Chess Pie Last In The Fridge?

As I’ve told earlier, if you follow the proper way, your chess pie can be stored in a fridge for as many as 5 days and this can prevent the top of it from cracking. All you need to allow it to come at room temperature after being drawn out from the oven and then go for refrigerating.

How Can You Tell If Chess Pie Is Bad?

Not only the chess pie, but all the organic products can go bad with time or if wrongly stored. And now the question is how you can find your chess pie has gone bad. Well, to sense it you have to follow if the pie turns soggy or watery and releases an odd- smell, then it can easily be said that it has gone bad to be discarded as soon as possible.

Can You Get Food Poisoning From Chess Pie?

It’s quite possible to get food poisoning from chess pie. If the pie is not properly baked, if is left at normal temperature for quite some time, or if not placed into a freezer bag before being kept in a freezer, the pie may turn soggy. This allows your chess pie contaminated by harmful bacteria. You may suffer from nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea, or abdominal pain. The symptoms may start within hours after consumption of chess pie. They even have to be admitted to hospital for treatment.

Read also: Does Pecan Pie Need to Be Refrigerated? Does It Go Bad?

When Should You Pre-Bake Pie Crust?

Pre-baking means pie dough is placed in the oven before the filling is added. If you’re looking for a flaky pie with wet filling at the centre, then pre-baking is a must-to-do thing. This process doesn’t leave the shell or filling undercooked and keeps your final product safe from being soggy.

Therefore, if you have a single-crust pie like banana cream pie, then you need a fully pre-baked crust. Apart from that, if you have custard pie where only short baking is required, pre-baking can do a good job.

What Does Chocolate Chess Pie Taste Like?

You cannot a chocolate pie as a kind of dessert where the chocolate only does everything. But there are different types of fruits or some other ingredients that also are included with chocolate while preparing a recipe for a pie. Therefore, each chocolate chess pie has its own taste to offer. In fact, a combination of both may create magic when you take a bite of it. Therefore you’ll certainly get a fruity-choco taste that can make you crazy while having it.

Read also: Does Blueberry Pie Need To Be Refrigerated? Does It Go Bad?

Does Buttermilk Chess Pie Need To Be Refrigerated?

Considering the ingredients you may find many similarities between chess pie and buttermilk pie. Because they both contain milk, sugar, eggs, and butter. All of them tend to turn bad if you keep them at room temperature for too long. A maximum of 2 hours is enough to keep them fresh on your countertop. But if you try to preserve them for a few days, then buttermilk pie similar to the chess pie can be kept in a refrigerator following the same process that you’ve done to store the chess pie in the refrigerator.


Desserts are always been considered a perfect Thanksgiving or welcoming dish no matter where we come from. And if you select chess pie for this purpose, all I can praise is your choice and intelligence for sure. Only a perfect host or homemaker can think of it. And when you have some more idea about what is provided here, you can even properly handle the leftovers for later use.

So, that’s all for now, enjoy your pie time, see you soon. Till then Good Bye and Very Best Of Luck!!!

1 thought on “Does Chess Pie Need to Be Refrigerated? Does It Go Bad?”

Leave a Comment